the monograph
The best way of learning about history and
understanding what history is and how it can help design, is to help make history, to help towards the
construction of history.
What is a monograph ?
A monograph is a kind of essay. Officially the word
means a description of a single thing or
class of things: Mono (single) Graph (delineation). That covers just about
any object or type of object, any single event or type of event any single
person, family or class of persons etc. It differentiates itself from the
essay, however, in that it is the subject, which takes centre stage and not the
personal opinion of the author.
The purpose of a monograph is to describe and analyse a thing in some
depth. In other words a monograph can be as long as a short essay or short as a
long book.
Objectives
The objective of each monograph is to present
accurate and reliable information about something in an easily accessible,
compelling and enjoyable format. That something might be a building as both an
object and a place. It might be about the life and work of an architect or
about a particular urban patch or a specific issue in architecture. For the
sake of brevity I have used a building as the research object here. In
investigating the life of a person or another theme, a similar model could be
devised by yourself.
Tying
the monograph to an issue or concern
Remember that you are becoming architects, research
for you is something that must contribute to the architectural debate. History
is not just about remembering. That memory has to be put to use. An architect
observes and records, he draws his conclusions from his observations and on
that basis, makes his decisions. Even so, the architect also will want to go
one step further, he wants to bind his own purpose to his research, he wants to
develop a vision of how that research is useful to the development of
architecture or to his own development as an architect.
For this reason it is always important, even when
doing a monograph, to look at the subject from the perspective of your own
professional concerns, try to understand the subject with reference to your own
development.
Constituent
Elements
The constituent elements of a monograph include:
·
A
description and analysis of the topographical context and setting of the building
both contemporary (when it was first built) and present.
·
A
detailed description and analysis of the Building as it stands (see section on
description).
·
A
reconstruction of the building’s history focusing on the changes in structure
as they relate to the socio-economical, stylistic and cultural aspects of
society at the time.
·
A
brief history of the building’s past and present occupants and their role in
the creation and development of the building.
·
A
drawing of the plan and elevations of the existing structure supplemented by
further sketches and/or photographs.
·
A
set of detailed and annotated sketches of structural and decorative elements.
·
A
proper introduction and conclusion (see relevant sections in Building an
Argument) in which the monograph is tied to a particular architectural issue.
·
A
comprehensive and properly documented bibliography and noting of sources.
Ordering
the monograph
The order in which these headings are given does not
necessarily reflect the order in which they might be treated in the monographs
themselves. Having said that, a self-evident structure is one where a
description or treatment follows a natural or logical sequence.
Time:
A description of the structure as it is now should precede a description of the
building as it was, as one can then use the building as it survives as a
reference point for what has to be imagined. A good model might be as follows:
·
From the present: It is helpful to start by
describing the building as it is now.
·
To the past: then ask yourself the
question: How did it come to be like that? With that question you dive into the
building’s past.
·
Back to the present: and when in your
description of its development you arrive back to the present, ask yourself the
question: What now?
·
And so to the future: that will give you the
chance to project the monograph into the future, tying the subject to your own
concerns.
From the present to the past, back to the present and so to the future.
Space:
The sequence of the description of the building, or indeed the treatment of any
theme should be ordered. Here are some suggestions: Order the text so that the
description of argument goes:
·
From
far away to close by;
·
from
the large to the small,
·
from
the overall to the detailed;
·
from
the bottom to the top,
·
from
the outside to the inside,
·
from
the front to the back;
·
from
the centre to the periphery.
·
Or
the other way around.
The
structuring of a monograph is different to that of an essay only in that it is
larger and you would find it helpful to divide your material into separate
chapters, each dealing with a particular aspect of the subject.